PnP Machine Evaluation
There is a general healthy amount of skepticism towards all these solution but since technology is evolving fast we might have reached a point where such a machine is good enough for projects like us that assemble a medium amount of PCBs per batch.
1 Liteplacer
500 parts/hour
2 cameras
1700€ for self assembly kit
https://github.com/jkuusama/LitePlacer-DEV
Useful thing to do with a LitePlacer
2 Charmhigh CHMT48VA
5.650 $
3000-4000 parts/hour
2 cameras/vision systems
Linux inside
two nozzles
number of reels?
3 Mechatronika M10V
http://www.mechatronika.com.pl/content/view/21/4/lang,en/
1200 - 1600 CPH
max. 40 feeders
supported parts range from 0201 to 40 x 40 mm
Automatic nozzle change (8 nozzles)
price: 14.600€
feeders add around 3.000 - 5.000 €
software, etc. not included so above 20.000€ total is realistic.
4 Borey
no reviews found so far
5 NeoDen TM220A, TM240A, TM245P
http://www.printtec.nl/contents/en-uk/d583_NeoDen_pick___place_machines.html
Reviews: http://dangerousprototypes.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=68&t=7097
6 Manncorp MC-400
3000 CPH
64 feeders
starting at $44,995.00
https://www.manncorp.com/pick-and-place-med-high-volume-mc400.html
http://www.smallbatchassembly.com/ got this one
7 NeoDen 4
New machine introduced in Fall 2015
can place 0201
placed component height limit is 5mm (http://dangerousprototypes.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=68&t=4903&start=495)
It has an integrated PC using an Atom processor. It runs Windows XP, in chinese. (http://www.eevblog.com/forum/reviews/neoden-4-pick-and-place/25/)
http://www.neodentech.eu/contents/en-uk/d8_NEODEN4.html
http://forums.parallax.com/discussion/153947/28-reels-2-heads-5799-pnp-getting-good-reviews/p2
If you get the non-conveyor belt option mounting PCBs does not seem to be very convenient: http://www.eevblog.com/forum/reviews/neoden-4-pick-and-place/75/ a user built his own system to take care of this (would also be an option for us).
- 4 placement nozzles
- Applicable components: minimum 0201, maximum TQFP240, can also mount BGA, QFN
- up to 48 sets of automatic electric feeders
- available with pcb holder or pcb conveyor
- 10000 CPH (vision off), 5000 CPH (vision on)
NeoDen has a global Network of resellers. From a european reseller we would get support, warranty in the EU and and the machine has to be CE certified!
EU introduction price is 7.500€ for the pcb holder version
- machine with stand
- 8 tape feeders
- vibratory stick feeder
Feeders:
- 8mm: 70€/Pcs
- 12mm: 80€/Pcs
- 16mm: 100€/Pcs
We would need at least 1500€ for additional feeders...
There is a lot of activity on youtube at the moment. Tutorials, demos and so on...
8 Visionbot
2000 parts/hour
3000$ - 6500$ options (depending on number of feeders)
"We have two VisionBot machines that are gonna be shipped nationally in Romania to two customers. One will be shipped next Saturday. We prefer national customers first, because in case they find any malfunctions in VisionBot, we are able to fix them fast. Unfortunately, we can not ship it right away. We are looking to redesign the feeding system (at least 3 weeks) because it takes too much time for us to create and manufacture the automatic feeding system within VisionBot." 11th Jan 2016
9 SmallSMT
Dual Head
http://www.smallsmt.biz/home/vision-placer-vp-2x00d/
6000 - 10000$
2000- 3600 parts/hour
Software is Windows only and requires USB dongle for copy protection.
reviews here sound promising: http://dangerousprototypes.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=68&t=7340
10 Novastar L-SF40 Benchtop
http://www.ddmnovastar.com/pick-and-place/automated-systems/l-sf40-benchtop
around 18,000 $
11 DIY options
OpenPnP:
The goal of the OpenPnP project is to design open software and hardware for a fully functional SMT pick and place machine for under 1000$. The software seems to be out of the beta phase and is used in a lot of other PnP projects. Also the sources of their hardware are available but still work in progress...
Homepage: OpenPnP
Video: Demos of Jason von Nieda
FirePick Delta:
The FirePick Delta looks like a very promising project. It is planned as kind of self replicating PnP machine. Based on a lot of open source projects it also uses OpenPnP. With a quick changing head you can select from different tool tips like SMT vacuum nozzles, SMT paste extruder or 3D printing head. Beta testing kits for 1500$ are out in the wild. For the promised ability of placing 0402 parts there is still a long way to go...
Homepage: FirePick Delta
Documentation: Beta Kit Documentation
Video: FirePick Promotion
3D Printed Pick 'n Place by Jtroncis:
A very compact and functional design. At the moment only a few parts of the machine are published on Thingiverse but a good source for ideas if you plan to design your own PnP machine... no public activity at the moment and no response to inqierys!
jtronic blog (german)
Video: The first job
Other builds:
https://amesberger.wordpress.com/2013/07/18/diy-pick-and-place-machine/